It was discovered beneath the Lonely Mountain (Erebor) by Thorin's ancestor Thrain and shaped by the Dwarves. I agree because Thorin did promise Bilbo first pick. He believes it will prevent a war. What treasure did Thorin want to find most? A. Later when you see the ridiculous (and even the word `ridiculous` doesn't convey how over-the-top it is) amount of treasure inside Erebor, it doesn't make any real sense that Thorin wouldn't just give Thranduil whatever he wanted … Start studying The Hobbit Chapters 17-19. Since Bilbo found it and decided that the stone would be his share, he is allowed to give it to Bard. 1 History 1.1 Background 1.2 An Unexpected Journey 1.3 The Desolation of Smaug 1.4 The Battle of the Five Armies 1.5 The Fellowship of the Ring 2 Family/Relationships 3 Trivia 4 Relevent pages 4.1 Gallery 5 Appearances 6 References Thorin was … Preview this quiz on Quizizz. What I don't understand is He feels guilty for having stolen it. So he doesn’t really care about how; he wants to know why. Thorin arrives and grabs him, forcing him to escape and run away. Why dose Bilbo take the Arkenstone? Now under siege from the men and elves, Thorin orders the dwarves to search for the Arkenstone, the most beautiful of the dwarves’ jewels.Rac tells Thorin that Dain is only two days away and ready to fight, but adds that the ensuing battle will be long and bloody, and that Thorin’s treasure may be the death of him. Thorin’s saying it matters how Bilbo got past the Goblins, but he then changes the question to why. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. I do not remember anywhere in the movies or in the appendices where Peter Jackson says Thorin needs the arkenstone to be the rightful king of Erebor. The death of Thorin II Oakenshield in The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies The growing conflict over the treasure between dwarves, elves, and men, likely to result in bloodshed, was suddenly averted by the approach of goblin and warg armies, so they instead joined forces to defeat their common enemies in what was later called the Battle of the Five Armies. While Thorin may be especially weak at the thought of money, he is still a brave and basically OK person. I know that on the His judgment is proven shortly. [2] I do not agree with Bilbo's actions because in my opinion I think that the Arkenstone should have been given to Thorin. My most valued possession is my iPad Mini. C. He feels guilty for having stolen it. A. Why did Thorin want the Arkenstone? He is angry with Thorin and wishes to end their friendship. Q: What Do We Know about Thorin's Halls in the Blue Mountains?ANSWER: Here is another thoughtful, long question that someone submitted back in … It is clear that Thorin needs the arkenstone in order to rally the other tribes of the dwarves. Gandalf travels to Dol Guldur, the abandoned Elvish fortress, and meets Thrain (Thorin's father), gets the map and the key, and makes a vital discovery: that the Necromancer is really Sauron. B. Everyone makes mistakes and everyone has faults. The dwarves are shown in their full character as the rather greedy creatures they are when they revel in the treasure that Smaug has abandoned. Why does Bilbo give the Arkenstone to Bard and the Elvenking? Thrain dies in a quest to claim a new home in Moria which is overrrun by orcs led by Azog. We want something, and we feel we deserve it, much like Thorin. Solved: Why did Bilbo give the Arkenstone to Bard in The Hobbit? Hopefully, before the end, we too can deny the temptations and Thorin looks for the Arkenstone, the most valuable object in the hoard. His judgment is proven shortly. 2 His Rather Adversarial Relationship With Gandalf Even though Gandalf is in many ways the most important member of the company that sets off to the Lonely Mountain (even if he does make some mistakes along the way), Thorin seems to have a very adversarial relationship with him, perhaps because he sees him as … A tenth part A quarter part A fourteenth part A thirteenth 5 of 5 Armies of dwarves, goblins and wargs arrive. Did Thorin ever plan to trade a fourteenth of his treasure to get back the Arkenstone? So I haven't read the book in probably 15 years, but I recently re-watched the movies. So Bilbo does have the right to pick the Arkenstone. The wizard commands Thorin to let Bilbo speak. Bilbo gives the Arkenstone of Thrain, 'the Heart of the Mountain', to Bard to aid him in his bargaining with Thorin. Part two My most valued possession is my iPad Mini. He is portrayed by Richard Armitage. Bilbo betrays Thorin by giving the Arkenstone to Bard. Asked by McKenna M #818153 on 9/24/2018 11:27 PM Most of all, everyone goes through temptation. No, Thorin was hoping that with Dain's help he could recapture the Arkenstone and withhold the share of the reward. Get an answer for 'Why did Bilbo give away the Arkenstone to Bard? ' It had been in his generation. Thorin has no choice but to agree, and he angrily He never said "pick anything you want except the Arkenstone" so why shouldn't Bilbo? Chapter Text Thorin was doing well. D. He wishes to be thought of as an honest hobbit It is clear that Thorin needs the arkenstone in order to rally the other tribes of the B. I'm starting to think that most of the conflict could have been immediately resolved if Thorin was in possession of the arkenstone. Presumably he wasn't asking for the Arkenstone, so what did he want exactly (and remember, this is asking about what he says in the *film*, not the book)? I want to know - why did you come back? A raven brings the news that Dain is coming with five hundred dwarves. The Arkenstone of the book is not that special, but it is nonetheless the most precious piece of Erebor’s treasure to Thorin, and he is buried with the stone in his keeping. Bilbo takes the Arkenstone and goes to Bombur, who is on guard during the night, and The Arkenstone, also known as "The King's Jewel", the "Arkenstone of Thrain" andthe "Heart of the Mountain", was a wondrous gem sought by Thorin Oakenshield in J. R. R. Tolkien's The Hobbit. How much does Thorin agree to pay out of the treasure to regain the Arkenstone? Thorin gathers a company when Gandalf approaches him. He believes it will prevent a war. Why does Bilbo give the Arkenstone to Bard and the Elvenking? (For more on Thorin's Arkenstone as his idea of home, check out our section on "Symbols.") I feel it was because he did not find it that his mind became bent towards greed. Play this game to review Literature. Thorin sought for it while exploring the treasure, and swore an oath to take revenge on anyone who knowingly kept it from him, but Bilbo stayed silent nonetheless. The hobbit claims that, in taking the Arkenstone, he only took his fair share of the treasure, as his contract as burglar had specified. What treasure did Thorin want to find most? The Hobbit, or There and Back Again is a children's fantasy novel by English author J. R. R. Tolkien.It was published on 21 September 1937 to wide critical acclaim, being nominated for the Carnegie Medal and awarded a prize from the New York Herald Tribune for best juvenile fiction. C. He is angry with Thorin and wishes to end their friendship. Thorin told him he could pick his share, so he did. According to The One Wiki To Rule Them All, "In the movie, it (Arkenstone) is depicted as being from the earth. This stone was the most valuable treasure Thorin will ever get. and find homework help for other The Hobbit questions at eNotes We’ve discounted annual … He steals the Arkenstone, almost without knowing why he is doing it, but sure of the necessity of it. Gandalf's primary motive is that he doesn't want Smaug to ally with Sauron. So, apart from the role of the Arkenstone as a claim of kingship, Thror did all he could (and probably more than he should have done) not to leave it behind. Thorin was furious when he discovered that Bilbo had stolen the Arkenstone to use as a bargaining counter, and sent him from the Mountain. His company was finally on their way to the mountain and making a good pace. They would reach the door well before evening fell at this rate. Many years later, when Thorin led a band of Dwarves to recover their ancient realm, their companion Bilbo Baggins discovered the Arkenstone, but kept it for himself. he could see that they were well supplied and would resupply the dwarves at the mountain dragging out the THORIN: It matters! What can you infer from his decision to conceal it from Thorin and the other dwarves? Conflict amongst the Dwarves, men, and elves was averted only by an invasion of goblins and wargs , whereupon the Dwarves joined forces with the wood-elves, the men of Lake-town, and the great eagles in the Battle of Five Armies. In Thorin's passion to regain his home back and the Arkenstone, a prized gem and heirloom, he employs Bilbo Baggins, a small clever hobbit from the Shire. In Tolkien's the Hobbit, why did the company need a burglar if the motive wasn't to steal the Arkenstone? Thorin, up until the end, proves rather unwilling to give it to him. When the goblins and Wargs attack, Thorin comes hurtling out of the mountain armed to the teeth, and he fights like a true hero right into the heart of the goblin troops. The Arkenstone is very important to Thorin, because that stone is the heart of the mountain. Thorin II, also known as Thorin Oakenshield was the deuteragonist and a main character in The Hobbit. I think he did this to settle with Bard after he had shot Smaug in the left breast.