Instant bond! No longer the open frontier of the Wild West, civilization (and trains, lots of trains) are sweeping across the country at a staggering pace, causing a previous way of life to be all but extinct. As such, horses are non-negotiable: the world would not function or make sense without them. In Arthur’s world, on the other hand, horses are more of a commodity. Same with only being able to carry a set number of carcasses and skins. Maybe you like the subject of BOTW story better, and thats fine, but in no way is it as fleshed out as the story in RDR2. Spider-Man for PS4 is kind of a perfect game. Your bond with your horse ultimately does boil down to a single number in Red Dead 2 – it’s very much a level-based XP system - but that’s much less obvious than in Zelda, which is very simple and game-y. The game is tied to a realistic depiction of a particular part of the world at a particular time. All these years later, there are tons of different ways to make serious money by playing video games. Subscribe today on Youtube. It’s basically like watching a movie. The game’s world feels more interactive and more responsive to our actions. The main missions in Red Dead 2 come with a heavy cinematic element, which leads to some incredible story moments. A few decades ago, the idea of making money simply by playing video games was a pipe dream. Zelda Breath of the Wild 2 and Red Dead Redemption 2 are rumoured to be heading to the Nintendo Switch this year. We have to give a ton of credit to Nintendo for making Breath of the Wild look as good as it does considering it’s running on a vastly underpowered console. Breath of the Wild allows players to build fires to pass the time, but cooking is restricted to specific locations. Yes, Breath of the Wild came out 20 months before Red Dead 2, but that game was a four year project whereas Red Dead 2 was in production for at least seven years, so there’s four years of parallel development there. Publisher: Square Enix For Red Dead 2 that’s not really a choice. Both games offer incredibly rich destinations, dense with systems and content, but little direct explanation. The secret to this is to focus. This is a super close call. Dutch and Arthur may be killers, but damn if they’re not fascinating portrayals of men coming to grips with their own mortality. No flaw will be glossed over. Actually having to retrieve things from your horse may be a pain at times, but it’s certainly an effective way to make you feel that there are physical limits to the world. So yes, you can simply go exploring, but there’s more friction there – it’s not the purpose of the game. That said, I struggled with BotW even more, and I think the breaking weapons mechanic was worse than any fun-busting infraction RDR2 committed as a game. Link’s Paraglider that allows him to glide long distances, is something that Red Dead 2 cannot match. Breath of the Wild vs. Red Dead Redemption 2; User Info: T_Info. Catching a wild horse makes a huge difference in getting around the world – particularly early on - as Link doesn’t have much stamina to work with, and thus is much slower on foot. And… yes… growing and shrinking horse testicles that we can’t show here without getting flagged. It's the battle of the best open world games of the last few years—Red Dead Redemption 2 vs. Join. (And, in turn, events that happened long before that.) It’s worth pointing out before we start making comparisons that these games were effectively developed in tandem. But Nintendo has put a … Horses may provide convenience in both games – just whistle and it’ll come to you! ... A subreddit for Rockstar's critically acclaimed open-world Western game Red Dead Redemption, its prequel Red Dead Redemption 2, and its online multiplayer Red Dead Online. Red Dead Redemption 2. But I’ll come back to that later. You stumble into them out in the wild and you’re never too sure what kind of challenge awaits you. Powered by .css-v0w4zo-Footer:hover,.css-v0w4zo-Footer:focus{-webkit-text-decoration:underline;text-decoration:underline;}.css-1wxdhtw-SiteLink-Footer{color:#1A1A1A;}.css-1wxdhtw-SiteLink-Footer:hover,.css-1wxdhtw-SiteLink-Footer:focus{-webkit-text-decoration:underline;text-decoration:underline;}Vocal © 2021 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved. You can also change the look of your horse’s mane and tail, buy provisions for it, and change the colour and design of pretty much every part of its tack. Stables in Zelda take on broader roles – they’re inns, cooking locations, places to buy crafting components (from Beedle), and most importantly, quest hubs where there are clues in the form of books and paintings, and characters who need help – or can give it. Zelda Breath of the Wild 2 is already … Horses are part of the “Wild” of the title, after all. Both games have story backbone quests that always occur at specific locations, and both games also have a huge set of quest-givers in fixed locations around their worlds just waiting to be discovered. Red Dead Redemption 2, Zelda: Breath of the Wild, and The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim are all large-scale open-world games. Although both are enormously successful, there are still some things that Breath of the Wild can learn from Red Dead Redemption 2. In Red Dead 2 we’re dropped right into the middle of a long timeline of current events. report. Focus and timing is key to surviving, whether you are being bombarded by hordes of zombies or just your average hardcore opponents. It's easy! At maximum bond your horse can also do piaffe dressage. Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube. How does Red Dead Redemption 2 compare to BotW for those in this subreddit? I can't even fathom how someone would think this. So… with EVERYTHING laid out on the table. 130 comments. outlaws on the run. In Red Dead 2, if you spur your horse off a high ledge or it gets caught in crossfire during a heavy gun fight, it can be gravely injured or even die. Breath of the Wild has these too, usually in the form of attacking travellers or mini-bosses, but they’re nowhere near as varied compared to what Red Dead offers. Presently, in any case, headsets are getting less hooked into outer equipment, and engineers are making first-party games that exploit the medium. Horses aren’t injured in the same way in Zelda, but they can be killed if you decide to ride into battle against a Lynel or “accidentally” hit it with a series of bomb arrows. Since both games currently hold a 97 on Metacritic, however, we … How does Red Dead 2’s historical setting and focus on weight and realism influence its game design? That should speak volumes of how great both titles are. He begins his journey on foot, then learns to fly (well, glide), and then moves to horseback. Horses have been woven into the very fabric of both worlds. It raises the bar moving forward on just about everything in terms of graphics—from lighting effects, to environment details, and … Today doing the most unthinkable thing on the Internet since “Superman vs. Goku”, by pitting The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild against Red Dead Redemption 2. Once you get off the plateau in Breath of the Wild, for instance, you can go in any direction and tackle the shrines and Divine Beasts in any order. Both games use them as a place to store and retrieve horses, but in Red Dead 2 they’re also places to buy new horses – with the horses available varying between stables and changing over time. And by the same token, how did the tug of war between the legacy of the Zelda series and the team’s desire to cast aside the shackles of tradition and do something genuinely fresh with the IP influence it? They’re all purely cosmetic choices too, aside from one exception: the Ancient Horse Armor set, which gives your horse additional stamina and allows you to summon it from the ether. WINNER: Breath of the Wild. If a horse dies, however, that’s it. Different saddles and bridles must be found in the world or earned – they cannot be purchased. From a functional perspective the role horses play in both these games is to simply make getting around their worlds more convenient, but that has been used as a jumping off point to do a whole lot more. Also, the structure of taking cover and popping out to gun down enemies can get a little repetitive over time. What’s wonderful about video games is that different games – and teams – can tackle the same concepts and ideas in fundamentally different ways. RDR2 & Breath of the Wild Have Set the Standard for Next Gen’s Open World Games. This core discrepancy is a reflection of the differences in approach that underpin both titles on a fundamental level. The art style they decided to go with here just suits the game to a tee and fits this new envisioning of Hyrule like a glove. Quite the opposite, it’s based on how many magical poos you’ve taken to a magical forest spirit for his magical maracas. In Breath of the Wild, on the other hand, horses – like weapons, bows and shields - can’t be purchased, so a stable is a place to register a wild horse that you’ve caught, and to store and retrieve horses. Zelda’s designers, on the other hand, clearly wanted to very specifically set the density of Hyrule themselves – hence the many shrines to discover and quest for, the 900 Korok seeds dotted across the landscape, the spread of stables, and so on. If you want to learn how to make money by playing your favorite games, here's what you need to know. Fans of about each genre have amazing options and can discover at any rate a couple of of games of enthusiasm for our gathering. For The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild on the Nintendo Switch, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "Breath of the Wild vs. Red Dead Redemption 2" - Page 2. And when that happens it’s time to pay a visit to the horse god Malanya (at a special fairy fountain), who can bring any horse back. Aaaand that's two and a half thousand words about horses. 11.3k. Horses are less central to Zelda, then, but they are still a huge part of the fabric of Breath of the Wild. After all, you spend so much time on horseback that working as a team with your horse is paramount. Some stables can be used to change your horses’ mane design and saddle and bridle, but only those with stable attendants – you can spot them tending to the horses outside the stable. Thankfully, this being a video game, there’s a variety of food and tonics to instantly remedy those problems. Also, the game’s shrines and other puzzles allow for more experimentation and trail and error, making for a much more involved process than simply activating a mission and following prompts to completion. While we could technically make an “apples to oranges” comparison here because Red Dead 2 aims for realism while Breath of the Wild focuses on artistic style, it’s clear that Rockstar’s Western Epic is the better looking game with its immaculate attention to detail. It’s not actually that exciting. It’s really a close call when it comes to whose gameplay is better, but we’re going with Breath of the Wild seeing as there’s just so much variety. For the sake of a fair comparison, we’ll not be taking Breath of the Wild’s DLC content into account, nor Red Dead 2’s online mode±mostly because it's not out as of the time of writing. Red Dead 2 has all these elements too, but many of them are bundled into its open world. I consider the PSP games a firm step down, and God Of War: Ascension would be fourth on this list, so there you go. The idea of computer game (VR) has been around for quite few years, be that because it's going to , up to this point, even the only VR headsets weren't entirely available to shoppers from either an expense or simple use angle. T_Info 1 year ago #1. Since both games currently hold a 97 on Metacritic, however, we can't hold back any punches in deciding which is best. How Red Dead Redemption 2 Can Influence Zelda Breath of the Wild 2. A badly injured horse can, thankfully, be brought back with Horse Reviver – a widely available item you should have in your inventory at all times. The main missions move the plot forward while Link’s memories fill in the backstory. Breath of the Wild’s weapon degradation may be harsher than Red Dead 2’s, but with so many attack styles at his disposal; Link runs circles around Arthur Morgan here. All that work bonding with it has been for naught. Breath of the Wild’s story, on the other hand, is much more fantasy-driven. Even if Rockstar failed to deliver on their promise that all the buildings would be explorable. As mentioned, the storyline is a highlight in the game, so completing missions is where most of the excitement is at, but that doesn’t mean we haven’t had a blast talking to the townsfolk either. For the sake of a fair comparison, we’ll not be taking Breath of the Wild’s DLC content into account, nor Red Dead 2’s online mode±mostly because it's not out as of the time of writing. aside from a couple of cool demos, VR appeared vaporware. Zelda, Breath of the Wild. Red Dead 2 is a technical marvel, and I was invested in the story, so that kept me playing through to the end. Would be nice to have my own copy of the game so I don't have to worry about returning it to him. Both games start with their characters in very different places. Sure, using a horse isn’t as practical in Breath of the Wild given how much climbing, paragliding and fast-travelling you do, but with 15 stables in Hyrule, you’re never far from being able to mount a trusty steed. Arthur has been with Dutch and Hosea for the better part of 20 years, and when the game starts their gang has fled into the mountains; on the run after a bloody incident at Blackwater. Yes, the Breath of the Wild sequel reportedly takes inspiration from Red Dead Redemption 2. It is, however, fancy. Racing horses, for instance, are typically fast but have low stamina and health, whereas heavy horses can take more punishment but are slower and more unwieldy. RDR2, presumably in a "bold departure" from Ubisoft, has lifted the approach to horse-whispering more or less straight from Breath of the Wild. It’s not even close. First, I might not be all that accurate, because I didn’t play all of the games you mention. They’re not a commodity that can simply be bought; instead, they’re out in the world, one species among the many that comprise the game’s vibrant ecology. Given that, it also makes complete sense for the relationship between Arthur and his horse(s) to have real-world value – history, stakes. The winner… but only just: is Breath of the Wild. This one isn’t even close. gunslingers here now. Indeed, you could say that the shrines themselves serve a similar role to the quests – or encounters - that players happen upon in Red Dead 2. Breath of the Wild, on the other hand, also drops players into a long timeline, but in this instance it’s concerned with events that happened 100 years ago. There are, however, some key differences. It’s the end of the 19th Century and times are changing in America. 6.5k. They underpin life in America at this time in such a fundamental way that they’re ever-present. With four tiers to work through, horse bonding in Red Dead 2 takes time, and the rewards are gradual too – its health and stamina rise, it can be called from further away, you can do skid turns and stops, and so on. While both maps are incredibly large and diverse, Red Dead Redemption 2’s is much bigger, and even goes as far as to include the original map from the first game. To play it, you don't need a whole command post, which is why this hit, undeservedly forgotten by many, should become the first contender for a revival on modern platforms. Arthur can have quite a few guns slung over his back and stashed about his person, but there’s a limit, and that’s where your equine companion comes in. it depends on what you're looking for. It’s all pretty full on, particularly when you factor in all the cosmetic options. So I’m just going to use my general knowledge about those. Arthur literally starts the game on horseback, and that intimate tie to horses never changes. These are games that want players to discover how they work and the things that are possible on their own. “I heard that a lot of people were playing Red Dead Redemption 2,” said Aonuma of the games that are inspiring the development team. Interestingly, Malanya will make a judgement call about whether you deliberately killed the horse or not and chastise you for it if necessary, but it never stops him bringing it back. Also I cannot wait for the 'GOW' reboot coming this year in 2018. Your horse has a number of base stats. Both approaches push the limits of open-world gaming, in other words, but do so with radically different player journeys in mind. Breath of the Wild’s weapon degradation may be harsher than Red Dead 2’s, but with so many attack styles at his disposal; Link runs circles around Arthur Morgan here. Though the world can feel a tad empty at times, Breath of the Wild adds features not found in other open worlds like the ability to climb anything, and the act of paragliding to quickly get from Point A to Point B. With Red Dead Redemption 2 for the PS4 and Xbox One, Rockstar has improved the open-world formula laid down by Grand Theft Auto, creating one … hide. And, it's not another new installment of the franchise, no it's a remake of the classic crème de la crème of JRPGs, Final Fantasy 7. Is Red Dead Redemption 2 Game Of The Year OR Game Of The GENERATION? Thanks for riding this one out, people. About 30 hours in, I almost fell off the game, but I pushed all the way through and I'm glad I did. Red Dead Redemption 2 sets a new standard for realism in video games and may just be the best looking game ever made. For Nintendo Switch on the Nintendo Switch, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "Poll: Breath of the Wild vs. Red Dead Redemption 2 vs. Witcher 3 vs. GTAV" - Page 4. Weapon degradation in RDR2 is way more manageable whereas BotW's was terrible. I finally got around to playing Red Dead Redemption 2. About the only thing you have to pay attention to while riding, however, is how many times you’ve spurred your horse – the number of spurs you have is based on its stamina, and they regenerate quickly after being used. But it was so close, that we almost ended this in a draw due to that last round. Gameplay in Red Dead is a cycle of setting up camp; completing story missions; solving side quests; upgrading and crafting; interacting with others; and exploration. share. Breath of the Wild's sidequests are awful and its wildlife can't compare. The same holds true for side quests as well, but they’re less restrictive overall. No feature will be underrepresented. Platform: PS4 Created Apr 4, 2010. *Phew* So Breath of the Wild takes the win. On the other hand, Breath of the Wild prides itself on being truly non-linear. You can play through almost the entire game, for instance, without ever even riding a horse should you choose. Breath of the Wild’s gameplay cycle is similar to “Red Dead’s” but is heavier on exploration and puzzle solving. And, if our conversations should get unruly? Prepare for the toughest scrutiny these two games will face on the Internet. Red Dead 2 has all these elements too, but many of them are bundled into its open world. The gunplay and combat feels more brutal and violent than any past Rockstar game, despite complaints of its default control scheme. Though the world of Hyrule contains tons of lore, once the game begins there’s little in the way of plot development due to the fact that most of the story is told through flashbacks. Okay I love 'God of War' games. Genre: Action RPG Health and stamina can be improved through bonding, while speed and acceleration can be improved – to a limit based on the breed and the individual horse – through better stirrups. As mentioned, there are plenty of similarities I could examine, but I’m going to focus on horses, as these animals are the base mode of transport in both games. It’s no secret that the original Breath of the Wild was inspired to some degree by Skyrim and the Elder Scrolls series, but according to a … There’s a similar difference in how, erm, accidents are handled in each game. It’s gone. The sense of… IGN Southeast Asia is operated under license by Media Prima Digital Sdn Bhd, Remembering 10 Of the Greatest Beast Wars Figures That Should Be Revived For Its 25th Anniversary, Here Are the Changes We Want To See in A ‘Final Fantasy XIII’ Remaster, Five Super Mario Games That Should Get the ‘Bowser’s Fury’ Treatment Next, ‘Raya and the Last Dragon’ Captures Even The Smallest Details of Southeast Asian Life. I have beaten all the main games, but honestly I only own 1-3 at the moment. At any point you can stop and set up camp, allowing you to cook and craft by the fire, and, of course to pass time by sleeping. Rockstar. Importantly, the act of catching your first horse also teaches important skills that are valuable throughout the rest of the game – i.e.